| Date of Baptism | Name | Place of Birth | Date of Birth |
| 22 Jan 1871 | Tillie Power | Conneautville | 27 Feb 1870 |
| 31 Jan 1871 (at home) | William Schofield Barr | 1 May 1870 | |
| 16 Apr 1871 | Mrs. Merrit (Dorcas Lawrence) Teasdale | ||
| 16 Apr 1871 | Julia Ann Robinson | 22 Sep 1870 | |
| 16 Apr 1871 | Percy James Teasdale | ||
| 30 Apr 1871 | Miss Josephine Meyler | 1836 | |
| 30 Apr 1871 | Sarah Francina Power | 1859 | |
| 30 Apr 1871 | Edward Melvin Lorimer (res. Madison, Lake Co., Ohio) | Dixonburg | |
| 14 May 1871 | Mrs. C.M. Rice | ||
| 2 Aug 1871 | Morton Klumph (adult) | Springfield | 31 Mar 1841 |
| 2 Aug 1871 | Emma Cooper Klumph (adult) | Conneautville | |
| 2 Aug 1871 | Jessie May Power | ||
| 2 Aug 1871 | Wm. Scott Klumph | ||
| 2 Aug 1871 | Willie John Robinson | Summit Twp | 4 Dec 1861 |
| 2 Aug 1871 | Claud Merritt Robinson | Meadville, PA | 19 Dec 1863 |
| 7 Aug 1871 | Martha Lawrence (age 30-very sick at home) | ||
| 3 Sep 1871 (at Academy, Albion, PA) | Patrick O'Hara | Elk Creek Twp Erie County, PA | 31 Dec 1869 |
| 3 Sep 1871 (at Academy, Albion, PA) | Adelia Ann O'Hara | Elk Creek Twp Erie County, PA | 16 Sep 1867 |
| 19 Sep 1871 (at home) | Robert Marshall O'Hara | Elk Creek Twp Erie County, PA | 2 Aug 1866 |
| 19 Sep 1871 (at home) | Thomas Marshall O'Hara | Elk Creek Twp Erie County, PA | 24 Nov 1863 |
| 17 Dec 1871 | Corine Maud Lyon | Conneautville | 13 Apr 1863 |
| 22 Feb 1872 | Richard Clyde Klumph | Conneautville | 5 Feb 1866 |
| 22 Feb 1872 | Archie Cooper Klumph | Conneautville | 6 Jun 1869 |
| 22 Feb 1872 | Wilbur Shultz Bollard | Conneautville | 27 Nov 1871 |