| Date of Baptism | Name | Place of Birth | Date of Birth |
| 6 Dec 1868 (2 Adv.) | Mrs. Frederick M. Robinson | Dansville, NY | Oct 1836 |
| 6 Dec 1868 (2 Adv.) | Mrs. Harry A. Brinker | Spring (Twp?) | Jan 1842 |
| 6 Dec 1868 (2 Adv.) | Mrs. Horace Power | Conneautville | |
| 6 Dec 1868 (2 Adv.) | Adelia Klumph | 2 Oct 1853 | |
| 6 Dec 1868 (2 Adv.) | Willard Sewell (adopted son of F.M. & Mary Robinson) | Mar 1864 | |
| 6 Dec 1868 (2 Adv.) | David Dick Williams | Conneautville | 17 Feb 1863 |
| 6 Dec 1868 (2 Adv.) | Josey Furniss Derby | 12 Nov 1858 | |
| 6 Dec 1868 (2 Adv.) | Edward Clinton Derby | 12 Jan 1863 | |
| 6 Dec 1868 (2 Adv.) | Luther Lavergne Derby | 4 Mar 1864 | |
| 6 Dec 1868 (2 Adv.) | Herbert Westgate Robinson | Conneautville | 16 Oct 1861 |
| 3 Jan 1869 | Charles Brinker | 3 Apr 1864 | |
| 3 Jan 1869 | Claude Hall Brinker | 17 Sep 1860 | |
| 3 Jan 1869 | Emma Anna Reynolds | 31 Aug 1864 | |
| 3 Jan 1869 | Erminia Elicia Reynolds | 23 Feb 1862 | |
| 28 Mar 1869 Easter | Frank Eugene Lowry | Conneautville | |
| 28 Mar 1869 Easter | Florence May Lowry | Conneautville | |
| 28 Mar 1869 Easter | Ann Elizabeth Lowry | Conneautville | |
| 28 Mar 1869 Easter | Lottie Evaline Lowry | Conneautville | |
| 28 Mar 1869 Easter | Miss Ella Louisa Sargeant | Conneautville | |
| 28 Mar 1869 Easter | Ida Cornelia Klumph | Conneautville | |
| 22 Aug 1869 (13 Trin) | Harry Howard Hammon | Conneautville | 10 Apr 1869 |
| 5 Dec 1869 (2 Adv) | Harrie Pinney Weigel | 27 Dec 1866 | |
| 25 Mar 1870 | Jessie Lee McCarthy | Conneautville | |
| 31 Aug 1870 | Florence Eliza Hammon | Conneautville | 17 Jul 1870 |